The Interview Questions That Reveal Your Best Fitness Candidates

Resumes tell you where someone has worked.

Interviews tell you who they are.

This is particularly relevant in the fitness industry where a candidate’s certifications, qualifications and even previous work experience can all be the same yet still manage to bring two vastly different people to the interview. When a hiring manager asks the standard questions such as “Tell us about your last role”, they are only getting to see the polished version of a candidate and only getting to see as much of their personality as they choose to reveal.

The challenge is that many interviews never get there.

Unfortunately, many interviews are composed of questions that a candidate can pull from their resume. This may mean that a hiring manager spends 30-40 minutes reviewing a candidate’s experience before asking questions about it, only to receive a perfectly crafted answer. The hiring manager is left under the impression that they have an ideal candidate, only to realize three months later that the trainer is struggling to connect with members, or that the group fitness instructor with years of experience is unable to accept feedback.

Three months down the line, they realize that the shiny new trainer that they had such high hopes for, is in fact completely unable to connect with members on the floor and that their legendary experience is absolutely useless when it comes to accepting feedback on their classes from fellow staff.

The problem usually isn’t the candidate.

It’s the interview.

The best interviews are those that explore a candidate’s best qualities, ideas, and responses to difficult situations, as opposed to how they will react in hypothetical scenarios.

Start With Real Experiences, Not Hypotheticals

It’s easy for any candidate to respond to generic interview questions with the “right” answer. For example, almost every candidate says yes to the following two questions: “Are you good with difficult clients?” and “Do you work well on a team?”

Asking for examples of previous experiences is also a bad idea as most candidates will try to spin a bad experience in a positive light. Asking for examples of past experiences is similar to asking for hypotheticals and are a waste of time.

Ask, “Do you work well on a team?” and almost everyone will say yes.

Those answers don’t tell you much.

While anyone can give you the best answer for the questions you’ve asked in a job interview, having the candidate describe real situations and their responses, allows for much better insight to how a candidate thinks, communicates, and solves problems.

“Who was the most difficult member you have ever worked with and what was that situation all about?”

“Tell me about a time a client wasn’t getting results. What did you change?”

“Whenever I work with a manager, there are times that we disagree on how something should be handled. Can you give me an example of a time recently that you disagreed with a manager on how to proceed with something? How did you handle it in the end?”

Real experiences are hard for candidates to make up because they require details and the more you can get out of a candidate about what happened in the situation the more you’ll understand how they think, how they communicate with others and how they can come up with solutions to problems that arise.

Look for Ownership

One of the easiest ways to tell if someone is going to be good at your job is to see who gets credit in a conversation and who gets blamed.

Some people blame everyone else for problems that occur at work.

The manager didn’t communicate.

The members weren’t committed.

The front desk made mistakes.

The schedule was impossible.

Occasionally that’s true.

However, when every answer follows that pattern, it’s worth paying attention.

In terms of acknowledging problems but also overcoming them, strong candidates will usually take ownership of the situation and describe in detail what they did to work around it.

They’re willing to discuss the errors they have made and what they learned from them.

This is a much better way to gauge potential employees than someone who has a perfect career with no mistakes along the way.

Ask Questions That Reflect Everyday Life in a Gym

The most revealing interview questions sound surprisingly ordinary.

Imagine that a member walks in the door 5 minutes before closing time and wants a tour of the club.

Your first client of the morning is very upset with their weight gain this week.

A coworker repeatedly leaves equipment scattered across the floor.

A new member is clearly uncomfortable joining a group fitness class.

None of these situations are dramatic.

They’re also incredibly common.

For everyday work, candidates can be better judged by how they would handle typical scenarios rather than extraordinary ones.

You’re hiring for the work that this person will do on a daily basis, not annually.

Listen for Curiosity

Fitness changes constantly.

Research evolves. Equipment changes. Member expectations shift.

The best employees don’t believe they’ve finished learning.

Ask candidates about the last book they read, podcast they listened to, course they completed, or skill they intentionally worked on.

Some won’t have an impressive answer.

Others will ‘get’ what you mean and get excited to tell you about something that they have been recently learning because they get a kick out of getting better at things.

That’s the kind of person who will continue to grow in the role after you hire them.

Don’t Mistake Confidence for Competence

Some candidates interview extremely well.

A well-spoken candidate that makes a great first impression.

That’s valuable in its own right but is not the same as capability.

The quieter candidate who pauses before answering is not the worst candidate, they may actually be giving the most thoughtful answer after pausing to consider the best way to answer the question.

Create space for both personalities.

Silence doesn’t have to be bad. It may mean that the candidate is really considering the question and not prepping a rehearsed answer that they can trot out dozens of times.

Pay Attention to How They Talk About People

Candidates reveal a great deal about themselves when they speak of previous managers, co-workers, and club or organization members.

Do they speak of past managers, colleagues and even customers with respect, even when describing unsavory or difficult aspects of their time with them?

Can they disagree without becoming negative?

Do they recognize the contributions of others?

Nobody expects every previous job to have been perfect.

The fact that a candidate did not have a perfect experience at a previous job does not mean that they cannot bring professionalism to your work place.

Culture Fit

“Culture fit” has become one of the most overused terms in hiring but it’s also one of the easiest to misuse.

A strong workplace culture is not made up of a bunch of clones.

It’s built by hiring people who share the organization’s values.

Maybe your business values accountability.

Maybe it’s exceptional customer service.

Maybe it’s collaboration or continuous learning.

Those are measurable.

Your interests or similar personalities to current team members should not be factors in extending an offer to candidates.

Different perspectives make stronger teams.

Shared values create stronger cultures.

There’s an important difference.

Watch for Red Flags Without Jumping to Conclusions

Every interview has some moments worth of further exploration.

Maybe a candidate can’t explain the frequent job changes they have had in the past.

Maybe they don’t explain their past jobs very well, or you can tell that they’re avoiding answering a question, or that they’d become defensive if they were to receive feedback on their performance.

Those aren’t automatic deal breakers.

They’re invitations to ask another question.

The goal isn’t to uncover a candidate’s mistakes during an interview.

It’s to understand the full picture before making a hiring decision.

Candidates deserve the chance to explain their circumstances and employers deserve to have enough information about candidates in order to make a very informed hiring decision.

Great Interviews Feel Like Conversations

The strongest interviews rarely feel like interrogations.

They’re conversations where both sides are learning.

Candidates should leave with a clear understanding of what your job will look like, your company culture, and what success will look like for them in that role.

On the other hand, you should get a sense of how they will communicate with you and the rest of the members and deal with problems and crises, as well as grow and develop as a coach with the employer’s support, and accept coaching, and how they will add value to the team.

Resumes can get someone in the door.

Interview questions should determine whether they should stay.

At FIBR we know that finding the right fitness professionals to add to your team can be more than just matching their qualifications with a job description. It’s also about finding the right people to strengthen your culture and develop long lasting relationships with your members and to continue to grow and learn after they have been hired. All of this can be determined by the right questions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *