Is Your Hiring System Broken? The Need for Speed in Candidate Follow-Up (Part 3)
Welcome to Part 3 of this series for fitness industry owners, executives, and leaders working to fix a broken hiring system. As established in Part 1, the fitness industry isn’t short on candidates. It’s dealing with a recruiting and hiring process problem, a pattern confirmed repeatedly through work with more than 40 brands and 600 health clubs and studios.
Part 1 introduced a four-part checklist for evaluating a hiring system: how jobs are posted, how candidates are followed up with, how the interview process works, and what happens after an offer is made. This installment goes deep on the second area: candidate follow-up, and specifically, the role speed plays in whether a strong candidate ever becomes a hire.
Speed Is the Deciding Factor
If there’s one word that determines whether candidate follow-up works, it’s speed. Anyone who hasn’t already read FIBR’s two-part series on hiring Gen Z should start there: Decoding Gen Z: Why Your Fitness Business Needs to Rethink Recruiting and Why Your Fitness Business Needs to Rethink Recruiting (Part 2).
That series covers a pattern that shows up constantly in fitness hiring: Gen Z and Gen Alpha candidates want to be hired fast and trained slowly. When connecting with applicants, contacting them quickly matters more than almost anything else in the process.
Most fitness companies already track “speed to lead” closely for sales prospects, trial members, or app downloads, expecting contact within minutes or, at worst, a few hours. Job applicants deserve that same urgency. Today’s future members often come from today’s future employees, and if a company doesn’t follow up quickly, a strong candidate will likely be working for a competitor within days.
Here’s a simple way to test this: apply for roles at your own company and a few others in the fitness industry. In most cases, getting any response at all will feel like luck, and a reply within one to two weeks would be considered fast. A response within 24 hours usually signals one of the industry’s stronger, more successful companies. The businesses that understand the direct link between fast, effective hiring and overall performance tend to be the ones leading their markets.
With that context in mind, here are the practices that actually move the needle on follow-up speed.
Stop Relying on Email Alone
Emails from new senders routinely land in spam, especially messages going from a business account to a personal inbox. Despite consistent guidance to call, email, and text every candidate, many hiring managers default to email only, then wonder why they never hear back.
A common pattern looks like this: a strong candidate is identified and screened, told they’ll hear from the hiring manager by call, email, and text, and asked to flag it if they haven’t heard anything within 72 hours. The hiring manager receives the candidate’s information with a clear reminder to use all three contact methods. A week later, the hiring manager reports no response, and the candidate confirms they never received anything. When asked directly, the hiring manager admits they only sent an email. Once they call and text, the candidate typically responds right away, but a full week has already been lost. It’s reasonable to assume that pattern has quietly cost that company far more candidates than anyone realizes.
Beyond deliverability issues, communication preferences have simply shifted. Gen Z and Gen Alpha candidates don’t default to email the way earlier generations did. Email might be the easiest option for a hiring manager, but effective first contact means meeting candidates where they actually respond.
Are All Those Internal Handoffs Really Necessary?
It’s worth mapping out exactly how many people touch a candidate’s information before an actual human reaches out to them. A common, and costly, sequence looks like this:
- A candidate applies on a Thursday.
- The recruiter or HR contact reviews the resume the following Monday and forwards it to a regional manager.
- The regional manager doesn’t open the email until Wednesday, then forwards it to the location manager.
- The location manager doesn’t review it until the following Monday.
- The location manager finally emails the candidate the next day, twelve days after the original application, and that email lands in spam.
This kind of delay is far more common in fitness hiring than most leaders realize. By the time that candidate hears anything, they’ve likely already started a new job with a competitor, probably within three or four days of their original application.
Auditing this chain honestly is worth the discomfort. Ask where every handoff actually adds value, and whether a candidate could reach the hiring manager directly within 24 hours instead. Whatever change gets you to that 24-hour mark is worth implementing.
Three Pillars of Effective Follow-Up
- Prioritize speed. In a competitive hiring market, speed to first contact is often the single biggest factor in whether you land a strong candidate before a competitor does.
- Use multiple channels. Email alone isn’t enough. Calls and texts, alongside email, dramatically increase the odds a candidate actually sees and responds to your message.
- Streamline the process. Every unnecessary handoff adds delay. Getting a candidate connected with the actual hiring manager as quickly as possible reduces friction and improves their experience of your brand.
A structured, fitness-specific recruiting process tends to build these habits in by default, rather than relying on individual hiring managers to remember them under pressure.
The next part of this series turns to what happens once contact is made: best practices for screening, interviewing, and ultimately hiring the right candidate. You can find it here: Is Your Hiring System Broken? Part 4.
LISTEN TO THE PODCAST EPISODE NOW
FAQ
Why does follow-up speed matter so much in fitness hiring? Strong candidates, especially Gen Z and Gen Alpha applicants, tend to have multiple opportunities available at once. Slow follow-up often means they’ve accepted another position before your company even makes contact.
Is email enough to follow up with job candidates? No. Emails from unfamiliar senders frequently land in spam, and many younger candidates don’t check email as their primary communication channel. Combining calls, texts, and email significantly improves response rates.
How fast should a fitness business respond to a job applicant? Ideally within hours, not days. Companies that treat job applicants with the same urgency as sales leads or trial members tend to see meaningfully better hiring outcomes.
Why do candidates fall through the cracks even when a company is actively hiring? Often because too many internal handoffs delay the moment an actual human reaches out. Each layer between application and first contact adds time a strong candidate may not be willing to wait through.
What’s a reasonable goal for time between an application and first contact? Many of the most successful fitness companies aim for a 24-hour turnaround from application to direct human contact with the candidate.
How can a company tell if its follow-up process has too many steps? Mapping out exactly who touches a candidate’s information, from application to first contact, and how long each step takes, usually reveals unnecessary delays that aren’t adding real value.
Does using multiple contact methods actually make a measurable difference? Based on repeated hiring patterns across fitness businesses, yes. Candidates who don’t respond to a single email frequently respond quickly once contacted by phone or text as well.